The Reformed Journal blog was born on this date in 2011. As I’ve recounted more than once here, I posted the first blog, “Do Calvinists Believe in Luck?” At least three people read it.

In those days, we published a print magazine called Perspectives. It was the successor to the original Reformed Journal, and while the source of many important articles over the years, Perspectives did not have a wide audience. In a 2011 planning session, Phil Tanis said an online presence was paramount, and suggested starting a daily blog. Before long, “The Twelve” was born, with twelve original bloggers writing twice a month. A guest blogger took the Sundays each month.
The original bloggers were me, Steve Mathonnet-VanderWell, Deb Rienstra, Jim Schaap, Scott Hoezee, Tom Goodhart, Jes Kast, Theresa Latini, Jamie Smith, Jim Bratt, Jessica Bratt, and Jason LIef.
Steve and Deb have blogged for fifteen years; both Jim Bratt and I took a break along the way before returning as regulars. Jennifer Holberg has blogged since she replaced Jamie Smith in 2012. Let’s hear it for consistency!

Names have been changed along the way. Perspectives has gone out of print and become the all-digital Reformed Journal. The twice monthly blogging schedule proved too taxing for mere mortals and we’ve gone to monthly contributions from most writers. This means we have more than twelve regulars. So we dropped the name “The Twelve.” Let it be clearly stated that at no time did we think “The Twelve” sounded snooty. Our standard response to that accusation has been “Pretentious? Moi?”
We wrote about the church and contemporary life. But no one imagined the extent of what was coming. Fighting over sexuality had begun in the Reformed Church in America by 2011 and there were dark clouds on that denomination’s horizon.
What about the Christian Reformed Church, you ask? I’ve always maintained that every controversy the RCA deals with is discovered by the CRC about five years later. However, no one anticipated in 2011 the winnowing that was to come in the CRC. Both denominations have fractured, but I will go to my grave convinced the CRC’s process was more painful—and unnecessary.

It must also be said that none of “The Twelve” anticipated that within five years Donald Trump, riding the votes of White Evangelicals, would remake American politics. In the halcyon days of 2011, Trump was the host of the television reality program The Apprentice and the guy who’d gone on The View claiming Barack Obama was not born in the United States.
We should have seen Trump’s influence coming when Obama felt compelled to release his birth certificate that March. A month later, Obama roasted Trump at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner, bruising Trump’s pride and fueling his politics of grievance. The country has not been the same since.
I’ve often said, mostly in jest, that these days we wouldn’t know what to write about if the CRC stopped fighting and Donald Trump dropped out of politics. Steve MVW and I have also said to each other (again, mostly in jest) that our best articles were written when no one read us. It takes time to build an audience.
Having said that, I also need to say the internet allows articles to go viral without building an audience. Kate Kooyman’s “I’m Sick of Appreciating Teachers” was published (coincidentally) on this date in 2018 and was our first experience going wildly viral. That post drew over 500,000 views, a testament to the power of an intriguing title (also known as “clickbait”) and Kate’s good writing. But those 500,000 readers didn’t stick around to read the next day’s blog. Over the past fifteen years we’ve built an audience that reads daily. An average day has somewhere around 4000 views. I may be hopelessly and foolishly Pollyannaish, but I think of our faithful readers and writers as a community.
Occasionally. somebody writes something that jumps the tracks and finds a wider audience. Our top article in the past couple of years was by a Dutch theologian about Donald Trump being an antichrist. It has over 110,000 views. I’ve written here before that the takeaway should not be that we published that article but that since Trump’s second term began, hundreds of thousands of people have typed something about Donald Trump being the antichrist into their search engines. Think about that.
The internet also brings an ungodly number of bad actors into play. So far this year our security devices have blocked over half a million log-in attempts from various bots and criminals along with over 85,000 spam comments. Those comments aren’t necessarily filled with obscenities. They are more likely to be filled with commercials and nefarious links.
I really don’t like bad actors who try to attack us. They reinforce my Calvinistic belief in sin. But I don’t mind comments by those who have different opinions. Allow me to explain.
Frederick Buechner famously wrote that doubt is the ants in the pants of faith: they keep it alive and moving. In that spirit, I’d say comments are the ants in the pants of our blog. They keep it alive and moving. I appreciate the comments our articles draw, even when they are in sharp disagreement with the author. I’ve published articles that have drawn lots of disagreement and articles that hardly anyone comments on. I much prefer having lots of comments, so please don’t stop commenting.
As of noon on Wednesday, we had 1,289,986 page views in 2026, compared to 1,289,442 page views in all of 2025. We passed 2025 sometime Wednesday morning and still have two months to go in 2026. I’m grateful for that number and grateful most of all for the people it represents.
Thanks for reading the Reformed Journal. Who can say what our sixteenth year will bring to our pages? There’s only one way to find out.
24 Responses
Jeff, thanks for your stellar leadership in this exciting venture. The variety of blogs is amazing. The gift of RJ is not just the benefits that come from reading these blogs but the creative outlet RJ provides for so many writers to develop a significant idea or tell a great story. I don’t think you’re being Pollyannaish at all to think of RJ readers and writers as a community. Thanks again for creating and nurturing this community.
I agree with Duane — in echoing my gratitude and that there’s nothing Pollyannaish about the community the RJ has created. It’s powerful. I credit the RJ both for preserving my faith on days when it feels weak and giving me a path to rediscovering myself as a writer. Both are no small thing. I sign up got countless email lists —and end up deleting 75% of my new mail on any given day, but the RJ gets priority and it gets read. It’s a rhythm that’s made a real difference in my daily life.
Happy birthday, dear RJ! It is such a gift to me – as a reader and a blogger. Just like Duane says, it is my creative outlet, and I am so grateful for the consistent opportunity to pull together into a handful of paragraphs the things I’m reading and experiencing.
I appreciate learning more about the RJ’s history. I’ve often wondered about the number of readers. From your article,
I frequently forward essays to our Upper Zoom Bible Study group, a ministry of my church, Suttons Bay Congregational Church. Some members have become regular RJ readers. suspect many other subscribers share articles beyond the traditional Reformed community as well. The reach of your excellent publication is greater than the numbers alone can show.
Thank you, and keep em coming.
I don’t know how this Presbyterian stumbled across the Reformed Journal, but I’ve been reading it every day for quite a few years now, and find it so valuable that I support it financially too.
Thanks to all the writers, editors, and everyone else who keeps it going.
This was fun to read, Jeff. Thanks for your years of work! And I went back and read the John Wooden and luck (?) piece. Priceless.
Love the statistics! I read this blog every day and I will start to post if I have something to say.
Yes, a very Happy Birthday! The various blogs are thoughtful and feed my soul as well as expand my horizons. I began reading when it was The Twelve and appreciate the fine leadership you give it, Jeff. Keep up the good work!
The RJ is one of the reasons why technology has enriched our lives beyond compare. Not only can we, your community, wake up each morning to thoughtful commentary on faith and life in this world of sin and salvation, but we can easily pass it on to friends and families. Thank you for fine leadership and such a grand stable of writers; our lives would be dimished without all of you.
I’m thankful for being one of the 4000. Keep up the good work!
Congratulations on 15 years! Enjoy seeing what hits my inbox each morning.
Thank you! RJ. Ditto to all the above comments. I did not discover this blog until several years ago and now look forward to reading it every day. It has been a source of great encouragement to me while still serving in the CRC that no longer feels like home.
I love to start my day with RJ. And I’m grateful that it has been willing to publish a few of my essays. Thank you to the RJ leaders and readers.
Kind of like virtual church for those who like to be stirred but not guilted, policed, or emotionally manipulated. …”a creative outlet” for writers and thinkers. Thank you!
Happy birthday RJ! I’m grateful to be a part of this community ❤️
Knowing of the 48 hours you put in every day, Jeff, it’s about time I offered you, Steve, and one and all, gratitude for giving us what matters. Your discernment and evocative writers sustain our weary souls.
I’ve been faithfully following this blog and have often forwarded many thoughtful and thought-provoking articles to my grown children and now to my grandchildren. Never miss a morning! And the topics are excellent fodder for robust discussions with friends! Thank you so much to all who make this platform happen!
Jeff, I too, really appreciate the history.
I remember a Dick Rhem essay in Perspectives that got him in hot water.
And now, RJ, and the broader readership of a daily blog. Thank you Phil Tanis for the idea, and the team for the followup.
Jeff,
I agree with all that’s been said already and will simply add my deep thanks. You and Steve have done amazing work all these years, and we are better for it.
Note: This comment references sexual abuse.
As a regular reader of the RJ, I am also grateful for the ideas that arrive in my inbox every morning. As RJ turns 16, I wonder if it can join in a conversation about sexuality that doesn’t often happen in the CRC/RCA: how can the church best reflect God’s care for survivors of abuse in Christian spaces?
I think most RJ readers agree that Trump lacks integrity and wisdom. Those issues are important to name, but they don’t necessarily make us look at ourselves with deep conviction. Kristin DuMez’s books also name some complicated and oppressive patterns in churches, but we can also read those and name what other people are doing wrong, since the evangelical focus of her research steers her away from the CRC/RCA.
Just yesterday, the CRCNA, as defendants, appealed a sexual abuse case to the Supreme Court of Michigan. About six weeks ago, a reformed church in Grand Rapids, as defendants, also appealed a sexual abuse case to the Supreme Court of Michigan. Can we talk about this? (Don’t say “we don’t discuss live cases,” because even at RJ we regularly discuss live cases, such as George Floyd, Alex Pretti, Cornell University, Enbridge and oil pipelines, and cases against Trump.)
The issues discussed at RJ are complicated, and thoughtful writers really do well considering various points of view. There really are reasons for voting Democrat, and reasons for voting Republican. There are good reasons for supporting gay marriage, and there are rational people who oppose it.
Sexual abuse is in a different category- there are not two sides to this issue. It is wrong. The conflict comes in when we value the institution over the survivor, and maybe that is something we can talk about.
For those of us who aren’t currently on the board at Cornell, the case of sexual assault there seems cut and dried: don’t rape anyone, don’t rape people when they are drunk, don’t advertise for others to come and rape people when they are drunk. Is it that much more complicated when a deacon rapes a preschooler in a church basement?
This is an issue that we need to talk about while asking “what if this happened at my church?” It is different than talking about Trump, who is “out there,” even though his policies directly affect us.
I know these are difficult topics to think about while we drink our coffee each the morning, but we need to do it, and I think RJ is actually a good place to do it. Would the RCA, or the Presbyterian Church, respond differently than the CRC to a lawsuit like this? I hope I’m wrong, but I actually don’t think so. The only way to predict how we would respond is to talk about it hypothetically: what do our actions communicate to the survivor, the perpetrator, and the community at large? If we can do that, then possibly the church will respond in a way that makes Jesus say “well done, good and faithful servant.”
All parents of teenagers know the amazing growth of complex thinking that happens at age 16. Let’s lean in and talk about sexual abuse in our own churches. These conversations don’t need to happen perfectly. Think about conversations with the teenagers in your, and how you might have said things you later regret, but these conversations do need to happen.
AMEN!!!!
We do need to talk about sexual abuse!! It seems as if we hide it and further accuse the victim by our silence.
THANK you for speaking out
Thank you for this PTA
Happy BirThDay Reformed Journal! and may there be many more. Your hard work and dedication are. appreciated. I loved the history you shared.
Nancy Miller asked Wes and I if we knew about the Reformed Journal in 2021. We began reading it immediately the next morning and sometimes we were still discussing it hours later. Those discussions often prompted knee jerk reactions from me which he tried to suggest I wait a bit before I submitted it. Sometimes I did but usually not. Now your statistics remind me how many people read those knee jerk responses! Now Wes is not here for those wonderful yet challenging conversations so it’s bittersweet.
Thank you again for expanding my horizons with the diversity of writers and topics.
Fifteen! Growing up so fast! It’s enough to make me want to blog again. Thanks to all the writers who continue to share insights and spur us all on.