Christian Faith and Secular Humanism: Beyond Forever War?

I’m intrigued by Jesus’ question: “When the Son of Man comes, will he find faith on earth?” (Luke 18:8). What is faith? What does it mean to be a person of faith? Faithful? This is more than an intellectual exercise for me. Some of my family members identify as atheists/secularists and have left religion, while others, including me, identify as religious people and Jesus-followers.

There are differences, of course, between Christian believers and secularists. But both groups have much in common. For example, Christians believe nature points to a Creator. Secularists also regard the cosmos with awe, without invoking God. Both groups believe the cosmos is more than chaos and has order. But then we part: Christians trust that purpose is built into the universe, secularists believe humans create purpose themselves.

Psalm 19:1 declares, “The heavens are telling the glory of God; and the firmament proclaims his handiwork.” Early scientific thinkers such as Isaac Newton sought to follow the “thoughts of God” through the study of nature. Later thinkers concluded that God may have created the cosmos but then withdrew, leaving the stewardship of sky, earth, and seas to humanity. This so-called “Deism” assigned God no continuing role in our journey and helped prepare the ground for the secular vision of life we experience all around us today.

Needing some help, I turned to the book Beyond Doubt: The Secularization of Society, published in 2023 and written by the sociologists Isabella Kasselstrand, Phil Zuckerman, and Ryan T. Cragun, for definitions which distinguish “believers” from “secularists.”

  • Believers accept supernatural claims as true, act according to established religious beliefs, and identify with a congregation, denomination, or tradition.
  • Secularists transfer property, power, and activities from institutions with a supernatural framework to those guided by empirical, rational, and pragmatic criteria.
  • Secularization is the social process by which fewer people accept supernatural claims, practice religion, or identify with a religious tradition over time. This group includes the “nones,” many of whom were raised religiously but no longer claim that identity.

Secular humanists and Christian believers both seek a good life, but they describe its source and purpose differently. Secular humanists seek what’s been called a “science of well-being,” while believers seek God’s will for the flourishing of the earth. What do these pursuits share, and where do they diverge?

My working thesis is that faith need not erase the differences between Christian belief and secular humanism. “Faith” can be broadly understood as a disciplined trust expressed through humility, responsibility, and fidelity to others. The question is whether this shared ethical posture can become a genuine bridge without reducing either worldview to the other.

Psalm 42 captures the contrast: God-fearers thirst for God even when God feels distant, while the secularist asks, “Where is your God?” and makes sense of the world without God as a reference point.

But how much of this difference is semantic?

Psalm 14 calls God-denial foolish, and says those who shun religion are “corrupt, doing abominable deeds.” This assertion may be true some of the time, but it is not always true. Secularists do admirable deeds, even rightly labeling certain aspects of religious faith as corrupt.

Both God-fearers and God-deniers have killed people in the name of their theology or philosophy.  God-fearers carried on the Inquisition from the 12th century, executing unbelievers for hundreds of years.  Stalin’s God-denying communism killed millions of peasants primarily between 1929 and 1933.

On the whole, though, both groups seek well-being, flourishing, and harmony in relationships and communities, even when they ground the ultimate source of the common good differently.

This leads to a possible connecting point between believers and secularists: the pursuit of goodness. Believers ground goodness in God, while secularists ground it in the quest for human flourishing. How far apart are they? A deeper question I’ve been wrestling with is whether faith names persistence in that pursuit or requires commitment to a particular creed.

The central question is whether believers and secularists can share a quest for fruitful living despite their different accounts of reality. More specifically, can attention to nature temper a believer’s emphasis on the supernatural? Can attention to mystery temper a secularist’s strict naturalism? These questions lead toward a practical test: whether both groups can pursue goodness together without denying their real disagreements.

Modern science shows that matter can be described as both particle and energy, deepening secular awe before the cosmos. Believers, meanwhile, understand Spirit as incarnate within earthly life, including us. Both therefore grapple with mystery, present challenges, unfolding processes, and future possibilities.

This world holds goodness and evil in tension. Believers may hope for life beyond death, while secularists may not; both nevertheless seek direction, purpose, and goodness in this life.

Are there any indications of possible bridges that can connect believers and secularists? 

In my view, both groups need a Job moment: Where were you at creation, 14.3 billion years ago, when the boundaries were set? Job learned awe and humility yet continued his quest.  He was humbled yet made it through to a better future.

None of us is self-derived: we enter life through relationships and remain dependent on intricate webs of mutual flourishing. Believers may receive this dependence as a sign of creation, while secularists may understand it through biology, ecology, and social life. Their explanations differ, but both recognize that life is relational and that offenses require forgiveness, repair, or reconciliation.

Each recognizes our own contingency and dependence. We are not self-derived; we belong to one another. As John Donne reminds us, “No one is an island,” cut off from the shore.

Life is relational. Each of us is poor and needy in some way. We seek both individual identity and healthy relationships—people and places where we belong.

We face reality and seek resources within ourselves and among trusted others— “beggars telling other beggars where we found bread,” to paraphrase D. T. Niles. This is true of secularists and believers alike.

The world is as it is, say the secularists. There are clear, sunny days and cloudy, stormy days. There are water and sunlight to make the crops grow.  As with Job, there can be horrendous winds that sweep away all that we love.  There are no answers to these mysteries. We only move forward in humble awe at our smallness, finitude, and dependence in the overall scheme of things.

Yet we rail against injustice when innocent children who cruelly die. Where does this sense of justice come from?  Are we to conclude, like Christopher Hitches, “If that is God’s doing, I want nothing to do with God.”

Back to our original question: “What is the meaning of faith?” Reality is a mystery, something (or Someone) we encounter each moment of our lives.

Britt Hartley’s journey from fundamentalism through nihilism to “no nonsense spirituality” illustrates a search for meaning apart from religion.  At a West Michigan session, I asked Hartley whether believers and secularists might bridge their differences. She replied that both groups need like-minded communities to reinforce identity; even when people want connection, they may fear surrendering a hard-won sense of belonging.

Her family experience makes the question tangible. Despite the gulf between her beliefs and those of her “religious” brother—and the pain of being “kicked out of the home” at sixteen—she still wants a relationship with him. Can we remain faithful to people with whom we profoundly disagree?

This squares with experiences in our nuclear family. Earlier conversations about our deeply differing world-and-life views (sometimes contentious) have given way to deep-sharing of the vast amount of love we share with one another. We don’t let our deep differences divide us. We use language that enhances instead of erodes wholesome relationships.

When each of us lives out of the primacy of love and refuses to let close relationships rupture, there may be hope for our shared future.

In the early days of the church, Romans sometimes considered early Christians atheists because they rejected traditional gods. Paul likewise dismissed “so-called gods” (1 Corinthians 8:4–5), yet in Athens proclaimed a Creator who gives life and breath whom people might seek– quoting Aratus, one of their own secular poets (Acts 17:22–31). He sought inroads into “pagan” culture.

Perhaps today secular humanists/atheists are renouncing modern false gods, such as Christian nationalism, while believers are seeking truer ways of following the crucified and risen One. Can we affirm both quests?

James, the brother of Jesus, in his New Testament letter, insists that faith without works is dead. Secularists and believers therefore each have responsibility for the flourishing of the cosmos: receiving and giving back belong together. Each has the grace of the given; each has the gravity to “give back.”

Faith, then, is trust expressed as fidelity: receiving life as a gift, responding through meaningful work, and keeping faith with others even when agreement is impossible. Believers and secularists alike grow weary in doing good, yet they can affirm one another, work together, and entrust unresolved questions to a larger reality. Such humble cooperation will not erase our differences, but it may help restore humanity’s fortunes and set the poor and oppressed free. At this point, such is at least a part of my faith. 

There is so much generativity in the cosmos.  We are to be co-creators for the benefit of all.

When I shared this essay with my nuclear family, they all agreed on one thing: It’s not a simple either/or situation. Non-theists can bleed into a “religious” modality.  Even Britt Hartley admits to community building that has religious overtones (but avoids God-talk). One of our adult children identifies as a “non-theist” yet as a “follower in the way of Jesus and as religious.”  Another adult child is glad we “share our love across the divide” (which isn’t that stark/harsh as I imply in this essay). Maybe that’s because we’ve found a way in our family.  In other families, not so much. Is it a goal to shoot for or will it be either/or?

I look forward to your comments in the chat below.  Thank you for engaging. 

Share This Post:

Facebook
LinkedIn
Threads
Email
Print

14 Responses

  1. …they can affirm one another, work together, and entrust unresolved questions to a larger reality.

    John, this describes the dynamics of my extended family as well. We all acknowledge a “larger reality” and human contingency. We all acknowledge that we are not autonomous and that life is precious, a gift renewed breath by breath, drink by drink, and meal by meal. We struggle to agree on the nature of the giver.

  2. O Tom, thank you for sharing the dynamics of your family matrix. Yes, so similar. “Nature” may be the Giver, I suppose, with no desire to entertain the notion of a Giver beyond/ before “Nature.” Hmmmmm. Joined by the notion of: “We are not self-derived. We were a gleam in our parents’ eyes.”

  3. It is worth asking, with historians like Tom Holland (Dominion: How the Christian Revolution Remade the World), whether western secular humanism is living off the moral inheritance of Christianity, since a purely naturalistic perspective does not seem to lead ineluctably to a vision of compassion and universal human rights. On the other hand, it’s also worth asking why that moral vision often finds realization only on the margins of Christianity.

    1. Very pertinent comments David. It does seem that burned out Christians are the ones who keep insisting on justice and mercy for the downtrodden. They are the secular humanists, sick of “Christian” hypocrisy and “do-nothing” pietism. They live off the fruits of the faith, without nurturing the roots of it. I’ve long thought that. They can slip into nihilism, giving up when nothing seems to change. Christian “Faith” believes that goodness will ultimately prevail, despite the “long defeats” we keep experiencing.
      The harmony and relational integrity of cell life seems to give them the notion that give and take, plus and minus are what life is all about.
      Thanks for engaging on this.

  4. Thanks for your thoughts, John. As you say, life is relational, and it’s important in relationships to find common ground in order to build bridges for understanding the “non-common ground.” You wisely point out many similarities between Christians and secularists, which have the potential of building relational bridges. For me, the main distinction between the two is that Christians have a relationship with God through Jesus (which is key to my idea of faith) that secularist do not have—at least not yet. And it’s that relationship with God that colors our every understanding of life. We both pursue goodness and flourishing in life, but it’s our relationship with God that colors what goodness and flourishing mean to us. Just as I might introduce two friends of mine to each other to expand the relational circle, so Christians wants to expand the relational circle by introducing our secular friend to our divine friend. We are not to be making “war” on secularists, but serving an ambassadorial peace-making role. Thanks again.

    1. Thank you David for your response. The word “God” is so problematic for secularists, isn’t it? Why is this? There are so many gods, David, all of whom I disbelieve.
      It is true, our God is the God of Abraham and Sarah, of Moses and Miriam, of David and Isaiah, of Jesus and the apostles (and Paul). But how this “God” is interpreted, experienced, witnessed to is not clear or cogent to many.
      They quest to decipher the mystery of life and purpose in their way. We quest to know this God in Jesus better and be co-creators with God in the New Creation that was inaugurated by the death and resurrection of our Lord.
      Thank you for reflecting that we “are not to be making ‘war’ on secularists.
      Allegiance to Jesus, as measured by our faithfulness to His body, the church, is lacking, uninformed, inadequate and often not helpful to our “secular” friends. Our witness is null and void.
      Thanks again for weighing in.

  5. I appreciated your thoughts on this complex subject; and I also appreciated David Timmer’s question/comment.

  6. Thank you for your article, John. I am inspired by your questions and thoughts.

    As a longtime fan of James Fowler‘s faith development theory, I found myself wondering how your questions would be heard by people at different levels of faith development.
    People in Fowler’s (late childhood-based) mythic-literal stage and (adolescent-based) synthetic-conventional stage often find their identity and related faith experience by differentiating from others—other religions, other tribes, other systems of belief and belonging. I believe this to be true for both the religious and the secular as they find identity and group affiliation in their “tribes” over and against others. In these stages, the sense of separation is typically an integral part of faith. In some ways, even your questions about bridging divides could feel like a threat in their faith systems.

    In Fowler’s later stages, systems of faith seem to evolve away from division as they embrace paradox, dialectic thinking, and truths that defy categorical explanation. Indeed, the transcendence of division in the direction of interconnection is foundational in these later stages of faith. Your questions of bridging divides would seem to resonate strongly with people (religious or secular) in these stages.

    Thank you also, John, for your references to Job and the essential role of humility in both religious faith and secular faith. In any stage of faith development, the experience of the grandeur of the cosmos as well as the compelling experience of Love lead all of us to—like Job—place our hands over our mouths in a grounding sense of humility. As you beautifully suggest, such humility in faith might be the true bridge between us all.

    1. Thank YOU Bill, for your contribution to this discussion. Insightful. Helpful. Humility and Love will show the way forward. Thanks again.

  7. C.S. Lewis and many others would answer David Timmer’s question: “Yes, western secular humanism is living off the moral inheritance of Christianity” and perhaps this provides the basis for the positive relationships that you describe within your family?

    1. Hello again David. I apologize for calling you Dick’s son. In visiting my neighbor, Ruth, she clarified you were a son of Dick’s brother, Joe, and work with Mission India. Relationships are important to me. Sorry. All the best, in your family, your work and your relationships.

  8. To the Third David!
    Our children were taught “the Christian Faith” and we lived it out as best we knew how at the time. What they gained was added to by trans-family influences, teachers, mentors, life experiences.
    As we all know, parents can’t control their children’s world and life views, and their ways of expressing how they make sense of life.
    Love and family togetherness continues to be a very high value across the board. We refuse to let differences divide us.
    What has it been like for your children David? How I remember your sainted father Dick, from whom I learned a lot about living (and dying).

  9. It is quite clear to me that the Greeks and the Romans were seeking truth and goodness and justice just as much as were the biblical writers. John Calvin often referenced their contributions with gratitude and great respect. Who owes whom indebtedness does not seem relevant to me. We need to honor these pursuits with the respect they deserve. There is much in life that we share with our non-believing brothers and sisters. We can and should work side by side with them and honor them for their contributions to the greater good. The areas of common grace are wide and divergent.
    That being said, it seems to me that the core difference lies at the world and life level of conversation. At this level there is a great antithesis which cannot be denied. I personally believe that we can acknowledge that openly while at the same time treating others with differing view points respectfully. God alone will be the judge. We are left to do our best dealing with the Jerusalem – Athens question with honesty and compassion.
    Thanks for your contribution to this discussion, John. I greatly respect our relationship.

  10. Dear Ken,
    YES, our thoughts and lives intersect at very deep levels. You have become such a trusted friend and colleague.
    What a good way of putting it: Jerusalem and Athens. Both in our cultural heritage. The differences loom large.
    Of course, the Mars Hill gang couldn’t swallow the “resurrection of the dead” then, any more than they can today.
    To “know” the living Lord Jesus makes such a difference. (And we must truly confess we don’t “know” God fully).

    I don’t think Paul ever hated the cultural despisers. He kept engaging them, hoping they would accept the mystery of a suffering Messiah of the Jews. He surely had his flaws and biases. Among which, cutting “Christians” off from Jews (although if you read Romans 9-11, you know he didn’t mean to!)
    Yes to respect for each and all, with humility, and love for each and all. Thank you Ken. Together in friendship and growth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please follow our commenting standards.